Written By: Pashmina Rupani
Regarded as “21st century residential schools”, Canadian prisons incarcerate a disproportionate and alarming number of Indigenous people, which places a significant financial burden on the Canadian economy (1).
Despite accounting for only 5% of Canadians, Indigenous inmates comprise over 30% of our federal prison population, and Indigenous women comprise nearly 50% of female inmates (2; 11). While the number of non-Indigenous inmates is steadily decreasing, Indigenous incarceration rates are trending in the wrong direction, year after year.
Legacies of Colonialism
Indigenous people are overrepresented in prisons for various reasons, the foremost of these being colonialism. Legacies of colonialism, as executed by various public organizations throughout Canadian history, have led to severe socioeconomic marginalization of Indigenous communities.
This marginalization manifests in multiple ways: income and employment rate of Indigenous Canadians are significantly lower as compared to their non-Indigenous counterparts, while rates of homelessness, suicide, substance abuse, and mental disorders are significantly higher (3).
Disproportionately Harsh Responses
“Overpoliced, overcharged, and overprosecuted.”
Indigenous offenders face the harshest criminal justice responses our system offers (3). They are more likely to be arrested and prosecuted; serve longer sentences; and almost half of the inmates in solitary confinement – referred to as “hell on Earth” – are Indigenous (4; 14).
The system is also flawed in its regimented requirements. For example, an Indigenous offender can be denied bail for missing a court appearance, however, if they are homeless or without transportation from a remote reserve, we can see how this requirement can devolve into a form of automatic, ‘Indigenized’ punishment (5). Failure to accommodate for specific needs of this vulnerable population highlights negligence on the part of the criminal justice system.
The Costs to Canadians
$121,339: The average cost per year to imprison a male inmate.
$212,005: The average cost per year to imprison a female inmate (13).
The annual budget of Correctional Services Canada is in the millions and has been continually increasing (7). The cost to house offenders, a large proportion of which are Indigenous, is daunting because of the hundreds of thousands of dollars, but also the fact that it is largely ineffective in addressing the offender’s root issues. Approximately 75% of imprisonment costs goes to employee costs (7). It is evident that most of the money spent on offenders is not spent on them, but their maintenance and surveillance. This means that after discounting fundamental necessities, infrastructural and employee costs, there is very little left to actually address, help, or treat the offender.
Contextualizing the Numbers
$19,498: The average cost per year of post-secondary education in Canada (8).
The cost of a Canadian student’s education for one year, on average, is around 16% of what it costs to imprison a male inmate and around 9% of what it costs to imprison a female inmate.
$66,800: The average household income per year in Canada (9).
The amount that the average household makes in Canada is around 55% of what it costs to imprison a male inmate and around 32% of what it costs to imprison a female inmate.
Prison Makes it Worse
The reasons behind one’s offending can actually be worsened in prison. There is an established link between exacerbation of mental health and imprisonment, which should be especially considered when talking about Indigenous Canadians, who suffer disproportionately from mental illnesses.
This failure to address Indigenous offenders is costly as well. For example, Indigenous women account for 78% of self-harm incidents in prison. They are moved to higher security levels, experience invasive surveillance, and are segregated from others (12). Along with failing to actually treat the offender’s mental illness, these measures all cost more money.
Within five years of their release, 38% of offenders reoffended, and 60% of Indigenous men reoffended, according to a Canadian study (10). This cyclical nature of the criminal justice system accumulates further costs per prisoner.
Re-allocating funding from more punitive measures to more supportive measures may help Indigenous offenders reintegrate into Canadian society, the economy, and address the root cause of offending. This support will be more cost-effective in the long run, as well as potentially help curb rates of re-offending (13).
Abolitionists call for tearing down prisons. The other side of that spectrum wants harsher punishment for offenders. Somewhere in the middle of that is reform. Many reports recommend legislative changes and reallocation of funds, starting with a focus on community services.
$32, 327: The average cost per year to maintain an offender in the community (13).
This is 73% less than what it costs to imprison a male inmate per year and 85% less than what it costs to imprison a female inmate per year. Experts have long been calling to explore alternatives to imprisonment, specifically for Indigenous offenders whose culture includes high levels of community support and a focus on rehabilitation (3).
This is not a new issue – the over-incarceration of Indigenous Canadians has been acknowledged by policy-makers time and time again, however, incarceration rates continue to increase, and the system lacks substantive reform.
Evidently, the system in place is expensive, cruel, and ineffective. The disproportionate incarceration of Indigenous Canadians is a costly and unjust epidemic; in order to outline a path forward, it is imperative to first redraw and repurpose our justice system.
(1) Youssefi, D. (2022, January 3). Canada must end the over-incarceration of Indigenous people. Toronto Star. Retrieved from https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2022/01/03/canada-must-end-the-over-incarceration-of-indigenous-people.html
(2) (2020, January 21). Indigenous People in Federal Custody Surpasses 30%: Correctional Investigator Issues Statement and Challenge. Office of the Correctional Investigator. Retrieved from https://www.oci-bec.gc.ca/cnt/comm/press/press20200121-eng.aspx
(3) Clark, S. (2019). Overrepresentation of Indigenous People in the Canadian Criminal Justice System: Causes and Responses. Research and Statistics Division, Department of Justice Canada. Retrieved from https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/jr/oip-cjs/oip-cjs-en.pdf
(4) (2022, April 7). Canadian inmates still face isolation amounting to torture, experts say. CBC News. Retrieved from https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/federal-inmates-solitary-confinement-enquete-1.6410882
(5) Macdonald, N. (2016, February 18). Canada’s prisons are the ‘new residential schools.’ Maclean’s. Retrieved from https://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/canadas-prisons-are-the-new-residential-schools/
(6) Dingwall, G. (2020). Welcome Home: Using Housing to Address Recidivism Among Indigenous People in Canada. McGill Centre for Human Rights and Pluralism. Retrieved from https://www.mcgill.ca/humanrights/files/humanrights/dingwall_ihrip_v9_2021.pdf
(7) Ling, J. (2021, February 28). Houses of Hate: How Canada’s prison system is broken. Maclean’s. Retrieved from https://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/houses-of-hate-how-canadas-prison-system-is-broken/#:~:text=It%20costs%20CSC%20%24110%2C000%20per,may%20even%20be%20increasing%20it
(8) Brown, M. (2018, April 1). The cost of a Canadian university education in six charts. Maclean’s. Retrieved from https://www.macleans.ca/education/the-cost-of-a-canadian-university-education-in-six-charts/
(9) (2022, March 23). Canadian Income Survey, 2020. Statistics Canada. Retrieved from https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/220323/dq220323a-eng.htm
(10) Stewart, L.A., Wilton, G., Baglole, S., & Miller, R. (2019, August). A Comprehensive Study of Recidivism Rates among Canadian Federal Offenders. Correctional Service of Canada. Retrieved from https://www.csc-scc.gc.ca/research/005008-r426-en.shtml
(11) Martens, K., & Needham, F. (2021, December 17). Indigenous women make up nearly 50% of prison population: Report. Apt News. Retrieved from https://www.aptnnews.ca/national-news/indigenous-women-make-up-nearly-50-of-prison-population-report/
(12) (2018, January 31). Marginalized: The Aboriginal Women’s experience in Federal Corrections. Public Safety Canada. Retrieved from https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/mrgnlzd/index-en.aspx
(13) (2020, September). Corrections and Conditional Release Statistical Overview 2019. Public Safety Canada Portfolio Corrections Statistics Committee. Retrieved from https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/ccrso-2019/index-en.aspx#b3
(14) White, P. (2022, March 10). Almost half of prisoners held in isolation are Indigenous, panel says. The Globe and Mail. Retrieved from https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-almost-half-of-prisoners-held-in-isolation-are-indigenous-panel-says/
(15) “A Progressive Facade: Comparing the U.S. and Canada’s Treatment of Indigenous Peoples.” Harvard Political Review. https://harvardpolitics.com/a-progressive-facade-comparing-the-u-s-and-canadas-treatment-of-indigenous-peoples/?fbclid=IwAR2FGA1BLxFbcb1O01wWMFZ4XMGVyqyEwRrRC4_bEgBdFapZALWwjDwz23w
1 Comment on "The Cost of Overincarcerating Indigenous Canadians"
Loved how the author was able to put this topic into perspective so seamlessly. A job well done!